Home Babes About

Home
Op/Ed

Dunkirk’s National Identity

Dunkirk and Our Crisis of National Identity

Tyler Cowen, economist at George Mason University and curator of the blog Marginal Revolution, linked to an interesting piece a few days ago: an alt-right review of Dunkirk that is precisely as distasteful as you would expect. Leftists, writes the reviewer, “fear Dunkirk because it gives white men a glimpse of a nice white country we could someday restore, and the virtues we must find again if we are to defeat the real enemy this time.”

Perhaps it is unsurprising that the alt-right would like Dunkirk. It is not an ideological film, but it is a patriotic one: a celebration of England, and of Englishmen helping other Englishmen. Arguably, its central theme is that of obligation to country, not out of ideological concerns — Nazism is never once mentioned — but out of duty to one’s countrymen. Its most moving scenes are powered by the attachment the English soldiers feel to their homeland: a general declaring to a subordinate that he can almost see Britain from the beaches of northern France, soldiers gazing at the White Cliffs of Dover from a rescue boat returning home.

It’s not hard to understand how this celebration of national attachment, through no fault of Christopher Nolan’s, could be taken as “a glimpse of a nice white country we could someday restore” by alt-righters. The sentiment is racist and obnoxious, but it does get at the film’s unique patriotic zeal, which has not gone unrecognized by liberal critics, either. At The New Republic, Christian Lorentzen complains that “in Britain the pious death cult around the World Wars remains a feature of daily life, memorialized on each anniversary of a heroic slaughter” and that for Nolan “Dunkirk is akin to checking a patriotic box and securing a pass to its permanent pageant of nostalgia and weepy self-congratulation.”

I’m not quite sure what’s wrong with nostalgia, let alone with Britain celebrating its role in the defeat of the Nazis, but Lorentzen is at least analytically correct: Britain’s national identity is, even now, tied to its performance in World War II. Perhaps this is why the patriotic impulses behind Dunkirk, generally so noxious to the trans-Atlantic liberal elite, have gone so widely unremarked, a bad review or two at The New Republic notwithstanding. You don’t have to lay on the Anglophilia particularly thick to wring patriotic sentiment out of the evacuation of Dunkirk; it comes with the territory, just as it does with Shakespeare or C. S. Lewis or even The Shire.

damn man, and here i thought it was just a damn good WWII movie from Christopher Nolan… along with a little history, since i’m sure most people (including me) knew little about “Dunkirk” before seeing it — got me curious, so i read up on it a little bit… and i figure if it makes some people read, and maybe learn something, then that’s a good thing in my book.

#geeeeshhhhhhh  #blink

64 Comments

64 Comments

  1. Thanks, this website is extremely handy.|

    Reply

  2. Extremely individual friendly site. Astounding details offered on couple of gos to.|

    Reply

  3. Great looking internet site. Assume you did a whole lot of your very own html coding.|

    Reply

    1. Incredibly individual pleasant website. Huge info available on couple of gos to.|

      Reply

  4. Appreciate it! This is definitely an outstanding online site!|

    Reply

  5. Regards for sharing your very good internet site.|

    Reply

  6. Exceptionally individual pleasant site. Huge information readily available on couple of clicks.|

    Reply

  7. Thanks for the purpose of furnishing many of these very good information.

    Reply

  8. Just simply want to tell you I’m thrilled that i came in your internet page!

    http://es.testosteron.space/

    Reply

  9. Wow because this is excellent work! Congrats and keep it up.

    http://nnet.it/

    Reply

  10. http://ko21.fr/comment-fair-grandir-son-zizi/

    You’ve got amazing stuff right here.

    Reply

  11. wo potenzmittel kaufen

    I adore this website – its so usefull and helpfull.

    Reply

  12. detox kuur kopen

    You’ve gotten very well info at this point.

    Reply

  13. detoxification juice recipes

    You’re a very useful website; couldn’t make it without ya!

    Reply

  14. http://es.cgtribc.org/sintomas-de-desintoxicacion-de-alcohol/

    Many thanks, this website is extremely helpful.

    Reply

  15. Thanks regarding furnishing many of these superb details.
    http://baraita.net/how-to-lose-weight-fast/

    Reply

  16. Incredible, this is a advantageous online site. http://baraita.net/titan-gel/

    Reply

  17. Wow cuz this is excellent work! Congrats and keep it up. http://machinalansu.pl/zielona-kawa/

    Reply

  18. You’re a very helpful website; couldn’t make it without ya! http://baraita.net/best-weight-loss-product/

    Reply

  19. Surprisingly user friendly site. Tremendous details readily available on few gos to. http://baraita.net/hair-loss-and-its-treatment/

    Reply

  20. Extremely beneficial, look forward to visiting again. http://baraita.net/the-best-ways-to-increase-motivation-for-training/

    Reply

  21. You have one of the greatest webpages. http://baraita.net/the-best-exercises-for-slimming/

    Reply

  22. Just had to stress I’m ecstatic that i came upon your site. http://laboratoriogiganti.it/fast-burn-extreme/

    Reply

  23. Thanks really practical. Will certainly share site with my good friends. http://baraita.net/nutrigo-lab-mass-conditioner-for-the-mass/

    Reply

  24. Maintain the great job and generating the group! http://machinalansu.pl/pro-flexen/

    Reply

  25. Various thanks, this placement is extraordinarily practical. http://es.testosteron.space/testosterona-en-el-deporte/

    Reply

  26. Basically desired to imply Now i’m ready and willing that i came upon your internet page! http://juventusdomo.it/dieta-settimanale-massa-muscolare/

    Reply

  27. Basically lack to mention Fashionable i’m happy I came onto your plat! http://fr.t-booster2020.com/traitement-testosterone-pour-homme/

    Reply

  28. Extraordinary web-site you’ve got aright here. http://fr.global-box.net/detoxification-du-foie/

    Reply

  29. Whoa, this is a beneficial milieu. ganar musculo haciendo natacion

    Reply

  30. credit a lot for your situate it aids a uncut lot. eroxel geeli

    Reply

  31. say thanks to so much for your web site it aids a fit lot. integratori muscolari pericolosi

    Reply

  32. symbolize thanks to so much on your website it assists a prodigious deal. ormoni per aumentare muscoli

    Reply

  33. I regard this website – its so usefull and helpfull. xtrasize effet secondaire

    Reply

  34. Great cobweb website! It looks truly businesslike! Keep up the good mission! http://nl.musclemass.space/welke-vitaminen-voor-spieropbouw/

    Reply

  35. I treasure perusing your internet placement. Thanks! http://it.detoxyn.org/dieta-disintossicante-giorno/

    Reply

  36. Exceptionally alcohol friendly placement. Titanic knowledge close by on yoke of clicks. testosterone levels

    Reply

  37. Truly, such a expedient internet place. innerwave detox ervaringen

    Reply

  38. Thanks with detail to furnishing such properly put together dispatch.
    dimensioni peni italia

    Reply

  39. Multifarious thanks exceptionally practical. Will portion website with my lofty friends. http://nl.t-booster2020.com/testosteron-en-osteoporose/

    Reply

  40. I ideal the info on your site. Praise! lunghezza del pene a 16 anni

    Reply

  41. Regards in the interest of sharing this striking neighbourhood. testosteron stimuleren

    Reply

  42. Thanks in place of the intention of present like sturdy write-up.
    http://es.cgtribc.org/desintoxicacion-de-alcohol/

    Reply

  43. I charge out of the info on your net instal. Thanks a ton! http://nnet.it/esercizi-per-rilassare-i-muscoli-delle-gambe/

    Reply

  44. Thanks exceptionally practical. Will certainly appropriation website with my friends. http://it.detoxyn.org/centri-disintossicazione-cocaina-milano/

    Reply

  45. Wow cuz this is indeed facts toil! Congrats and keep it up. http://nl.cgtribc.org/detox-formule-proefpakket/

    Reply

  46. Thanks! It is definitely an astounding web-site. http://ko21.fr/ultimo-deseo/

    Reply

  47. Thanks pertaining to giving this strain of remarkable tidings.
    erectie verlengen

    Reply

  48. Giant looking web locality. Suspect you did a inordinate apportion of your quite own coding. detox organizmu

    Reply

  49. I enjoy looking through your web sites. Thanks seeking your often! http://portassicurazioni.it/estensore-per-il-pene/

    Reply

  50. Horrifying entanglement locale you’ve got here. aumentare massa muscolare nuoto

    Reply

  51. Take care of the massive job and bringing in the group! détoxification foie effets secondaires

    Reply

  52. I dig the acquaintanceship on your internet location. Thnx. http://nl.t-booster2020.com/testosteron-bewaren/

    Reply

  53. Simply rightful desired to style Intermittently i am lucky I stumbled onto your website. m’lis detoxification kit reviews

    Reply

  54. Awe-inspiring, such a vital net number. comment booster sa testostérone naturellement

    Reply

  55. Nice internet neighbourhood you acquire aright here. http://juventusdomo.it/creatina-aminoacidi/

    Reply

  56. Hi-ya, fair web purlieus you have in here. aumentar la masa muscular comida

    Reply

  57. Wow because this is hellishly orderly work! Congrats and victual it up. http://it.global-box.net/centro-disintossicazione-gioco/

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.